So several months ago, I got an email from a friend of mine. She and her husband were planning a once-in-a-lifetime trip to Berlin this summer for their family of 6 and wanted my help in figuring out how they could use miles to defray the cost. Her husband’s expenses were being covered by his employer, but they were looking for how to get the other 5 of them there with miles. I wrote a post back in the spring about how they could get it done.
The trip happened this past summer and I could tell from Facebook that they had a great time. I was curious as to whether or not they were able to get the flights for free or not, so I asked for a trip report.
Here’s Harmony with the details!
The plan
So, your post about how to get five of us to Berlin for free suggested going with American on the outbound flight using a stopover in a gateway city (PWaC: Note that American no longer allows these free stopovers) so we could take advantage of off-peak fares and do it for 100,000 points instead of 150,000 points. Then the return trip would be with United for 150,000 points. The credit cards you suggested were two Chase InkPlus business cards, a Chase Sapphire card, a Chase Southwest card, and two Citi AAdvantage cards, giving us a total of 158,000 Chase Rewards points which transfer to United 1:1, 52,000 Southwest Rapid Rewards points, and 106,000 American AAdvantage points.
It was a good plan, but we were not totally successful with it for several reasons:What went wrong
1. We simply should have started earlier. Our travel time frame was late May thru June. We did our first churns at the end of January. If we had churned 3-4 months earlier, I think we could have made the whole plan work exactly as intended, especially considering we had some fairly expensive auto repairs in October or November that would have helped with our spending. And if we had completed the spending earlier, we would have been able to book earlier when there were more options for rewards tickets still available. Hindsight is 20/20.
2. Spending was a challenge. We did use Amazon Payments (PWaC – As of October 13, 2014, Amazon Payments will no longer be possible) to make some payments to trusted relatives, which helped, but Amazon’s monthly limits kept that to a minimum, especially within our time frame. The most helpful “manufactured” spending method we used was purchasing Vanilla Reload cards from CVS and then loading them on an American Express Bluebird account, which I then used to pay our mortgage and a few other bills for three months. This was effective, but not without plenty of hassle. After much searching I discovered CVS was the only place I could buy the right Vanilla Reload cards. And there is only one CVS store in our neck of the woods, about a 30 minute drive away. And, at least to start with, most of the times I drove down there to purchase them they were sold out of the cards. I had a little more success after an employee told me when their new shipment usually came in each week, but it was very obvious that I was not the only person out there trying to manufacture spending this way. I also found myself not being quite as careful with my normal household spending, justifying some expenditures as a way to help make this trip happen–not the smartest thing I realize, but at least I recognized what I was doing while I was doing it. 🙂
3. We were approved immediately for most of the cards we applied for. The Chase InkPlus business cards were the only exception. I called to have mine reconsidered (or whatever they call it) and got approved. My husband didn’t want to bother, in part because he hates talking on the phone, and in part because neither of us were super thrilled about trying to justify a business card for our EBay accounts. So that was just wimpy on our part. On the other hand, coming up with $5000 more spending on that sixth card within our time limitations would have been difficult anyway.4. Sometimes life gets in the way of the best laid plans. More on that later.
So I started the spending with the Southwest card and the two American cards, in order to book the outbound flight as soon as possible. When I got enough points to book, the plan to start the trip with an American domestic flight to a gateway city (Dallas) during offpeak for a stopover, fly home that same day on Southwest, then return to Dallas on Southwest when we wanted to continue with our American leg to Germany in late May/early June wasn’t an option anymore. I think the American flights (that weren’t British Airways) from SLC to Dallas had disappeared from the schedule–or maybe they just weren’t available for rewards travel by the time I got to them. I checked several other options for other American gateway cities, including Chicago where my parents had been called on a mission and could help transport us between ORD and MDW, but I couldn’t find anything else that worked. The reward flights that were available required more points than the 100,000 I had, so trying to travel offpeak wasn’t helpful anymore. In the end, squeezing in an extra domestic flight with four children was stress I was glad not to deal with.
I kept spending and kept trying to work out a new plan. Nothing quite fell into place as I’d hoped, but I’d gone to plenty of trouble, and I had points, and I was determined to use them as well as I could. Then, somewhere in the middle of trying to figure everything out, life happened. In mid-April found out I had a kidney disease which could have prevented me from flying altogether–meaning trip cancelled. It took almost a month–to get tested, diagnosed, on meds, and finally get clearance from my doctor to travel. So by the time I could make a new plan happen, we were just outside of two weeks of when we wanted to leave, and there were even fewer rewards flights available anywhere close to my point range. Needless to say, I had to scramble.
I’m leaving out lots of details I’m sure you’d love to have, but I just don’t remember all the steps I took and in what order. I wish I’d written them all down as I went, but the spending and the kidney mess was about all I could handle on top of everyday life–and with Jeff already in Germany. If I remember right, I ended up with 50,000+ Southwest points, 100,000+ American points, and 100,000+ United points. I think when I looked for American flights from SLC to TXL that weren’t British Airways (with the astronomical fees/fuel surcharges), there just weren’t any options. I don’t remember exactly how I came up with the plan I did, but I ended up going back to the Chicago idea so I could have my parents help us.
The final itinerary
Here is what our itinerary ended up looking like, with prices:
SLC-MDW on Frontier Airlines–55,200 Chase points + $80 for luggage + $30 to choose seats
ORD-FCO-TXL on American Airlines & Air Berlin–100,000 American points + $690 to transfer Jeff’s points to my account so I could get all the tickets on one itinerary + $235.50 fees/fuel + $1104.25 to buy add’l points
TXL-FRA-LAS on Condor Airlines, a discount airline based in Germany that offers child tickets for 75% of adult fare–$3042.43
LAS-SLC on Delta Airlines–35,600 Chase points + $100 for luggage
Total cash damage–$5272.18
Points leftover (and accumulated since) for a future trip–I’m thinking a getaway for Jeff and me on a Southwest flight with a hotel though Chase:
Chase–28,588
American–11,209
Southwest–50,610
In the end, I figure we saved about $3000 on plane tickets–not as much as I’d hoped, but nothing to sniff at either. We definitely could have saved more under different circumstances. Bottom line though, we had a fantastic trip–including a bonus overnighter with my parents on their mission, and feet on the ground in Italy for a short layover. We created some great family memories and we don’t regret a thing. In fact, Jeff doesn’t even want me to add up how much the whole trip cost (travel, housing, food, etc.) because it’s water under the bridge and it was worth it, whatever it cost. (As wonderful as it was, it won’t be happening again anytime soon though, because we’ve got four boys to send on missions in the next decade or so.)
Again, thanks so much for your help and support to make it happen.
I’m glad I was able to help – hopefully everyone else was also able to enjoy the trip report. I think that the #1 takeaway is the need to plan big trips further in advance. With large families, there’s an extra need to plan further out, because it’s harder to get multiple award tickets (though Jason Steele had some good tips on that at #FT4RL conference)
Had a once-in-a-lifetime trip with your family? Leave us a note in the comments
This site is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as thepointsguy.com. This may impact how and where links appear on this site. Responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Some or all of the card offers that appear on the website are from advertisers and that compensation may impact on how and where card products appear on the site. Any opinions expressed in this post are my own, and have not been reviewed, approved, or endorsed by my advertising partners and I do not include all card companies, or all available card offers. Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers and other offers and benefits listed on this page. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Other links on this page may also pay me a commission - as always, thanks for your support if you use them
User Generated Content Disclosure: Points With a Crew encourages constructive discussions, comments, and questions. Responses are not provided by or commissioned by any bank advertisers. These responses have not been reviewed, approved, or endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the responsibility of the bank advertiser to respond to comments.
Dan Miller travels with his wife and 6 (SIX!) children. He loves to help families travel for free / cheap, especially larger families. If you are looking for help, drop him an email at 
Great recap! Here’s a helpful tip for the future when you call AA and you have to get the award booked out of multiple accounts:
-Get the ticket priced out for all passengers
-Then explain that you would like to split the PNR so that you can pay for the award travel out of two separate accounts.
-This will keep all the PNRs linked together. I’ve successfully called in more than once on my upcoming award that has such scenario, and they’ve always seen the two linked PNRs together.
– in case if IRROPS, everyone should be kept together.
– no need to pay transfer fees from one account to another.
Ben – thanks! That’s a great tip1
As a Mom of 4, I found this very interesting! I’ve commented before that we are planning a Europe trip for 5 of us (oldest child has to work) for Summer of 2016. We have combined 215k AA/US Air miles. If we want to go in summer, we’ll need another 85k miles….ugh. So, we need to apply quickly and get those points before seats open up for next summer. In the meantime, we are working on those hotel points. I’ve forced my husband to ditch his Marriott loyalty, and he’s already accrued 80k Club Carlson points with just 5 stays. That CC will be next so we can take advantage of the BOGO benefit. Thanks so much for your great informative posts 🙂
You’re welcome Stacy! Make sure to sign up for our daily email newsletter if you haven’t already to make sure you never miss another post